Sunday, September 20, 2009

Labatt-Molson drama like a plot from Twin Peaks

Had the beer lost its smooth easy drinking taste or was that just the taste of irony?

Only three weeks ago, Labatt Brewing Co. slapped Brick Brewing Co with a law suit for trademark infringement. Now it seems fate has turned around at slapped back. The initial controversy was that the Brick Brewing Co.'s (marketers of the Red Baron Lime lager) packaging and marketing strategies were too similar to that of Bud light Lime. Now it seems that Labatt has been hit with a similar suit, accusing them of infringing on Coors Light and their new ad campaign for its Kokanee Brand.

The trademark and copyright suit was filed Monday. Molson Coors Canada argues that the mountain range icon is confusingly similar to the Coors light mountain icon. Molson expects $10 million in return and an end of the use to the Kokanee icon. Labatt explains that they have used the mountain range icon since the 1960's in their advertising and are not under the impression that there is any potential consumer confusion.

Molson does not like the fact that Labatt has made the addition of a second mountain to their mountain range image, the higher peak being on the right. The Coors icon is the reversal. Due solely to the fact that people may be liable to mistake the icon for Coors Mountain, Molson also plans to prevent the Kokanee icon from being used as a standalone logo. Essentially giving Labatt a line that they cannot cross, and if that line is crossed, saying we've got a problem with that. On the whole, it is a story of David and Goliath, Labatt  is essentially being bullied off the mountains.


My opinion:

I think that Labatt Brewing Co. will not be guilty for the trademark and copyright allegations. This will just pass as a warning to competing industries to stress originality. Furthermore, I believe that there will not be any consumer confusion between Labatt’s Kokanee beer and Molson's Coors light. I justify my opinion below:

Factors that evoke similarities include color, design, and texture. First off, the mountain ranges of British Columbia are the birthplace of Kokanee beer. Now I find it ironic that what is real has to be restricted. In addition, they use two distinct colors groupings: Coors black, red, white, silver, and Kokanee using more of the darker tones. Lastly, the Kokanee design is realistic, while Coors has more aggressive and futuristic attributes to it.

No comments: